Should Landlords Allow Pets?

Jason McGuire • September 29, 2025

Protecting Your Property Without Losing Great Tenants

In Pensacola, Milton, and across Northwest Florida, pets are part of the family. Surveys show that nearly 70% of U.S. households have a pet, and many renters specifically search for “pet-friendly” homes.


So what should landlords do—allow pets and risk property damage, or say no and risk losing great tenants? Let’s break down the pros, cons, and smart ways to handle pets in your rental property.


Step 1: The Upside of Allowing Pets

There are real benefits to opening your doors to tenants with pets:

Larger tenant pool → Attract more applicants, reducing vacancy time.
Higher rent potential → Pet-friendly homes often command premium rent.
Longer lease terms → Pet owners are less likely to move frequently since pet-friendly rentals are harder to find.


Allowing pets can give your property a competitive edge in the Pensacola rental market.


Step 2: The Risks of Pets in Rentals

Of course, pets can bring challenges:

• Property damage (scratched floors, chewed trim, stained carpets)
• Odors that require deep cleaning at turnover
• Noise complaints from neighbors
• Liability concerns if a pet injures someone


These risks are why many landlords hesitate. But with the right systems, risks can be minimized.


Step 3: Use Pet Deposits and Fees Legally

Florida law allows landlords to charge pet deposits or non-refundable pet fees—as long as they’re clearly outlined in the lease. This helps cover cleaning and minor damage.


Important exceptions:
Service animals and emotional support animals (ESAs) are not “pets” under the law. Landlords cannot charge deposits or deny them.
• Pet policies must comply with fair housing regulations.


Step 4: Screen Pets Like You Screen Tenants

Just as you verify credit, income, and rental history for tenants, you can require:

• Pet application forms with details on breed, size, and age
• Vet records for vaccinations
• References from prior landlords


This protects your property while keeping responsible pet owners welcome.


How Clover Property Management Handles Pets

Clover helps landlords balance tenant demand with property protection.

🍀 Pet screening and application process
🍀 Enforceable pet policies in every lease
🍀 Collection of pet deposits and fees within Florida law
🍀 Regular inspections to catch issues early
🍀 Clear separation of “pets” vs. service animals to avoid legal mistakes


We make it possible to say “yes” to pets—without risking your investment.


Don’t Miss Out on Great Tenants


Pets are here to stay. The real question isn’t should landlords allow pets, but how can you allow them safely? Clover Property Management provides the systems, policies, and protections that let you enjoy the benefits while minimizing the risks.


📲 Visit www.CloverPM.com or call 850-994-1542 for a free consultation on managing your rental property.


Your tenants stay happy. Your property stays protected. Everyone wins.

You might also like

Clover Property Management Resources

By Jason McGuire September 25, 2025
The Hidden Costs of Hiring a Cheap Property Manager
Hand Shake and Trust
By Jason McGuire September 22, 2025
Trusted by Pensacola, Milton, and Pace homeowners, Clover Property Management delivers reliable rent collection, proactive maintenance, and legal compliance for stress-free rental ownership.
By Jason McGuire September 19, 2025
Are DIY Landlords Hurting the Rental Market in Pensacola? More and more homeowners in Pensacola, Milton, and Pace are deciding to rent out their properties themselves. On the surface, it seems like a good idea: save the management fee and handle things directly. But here’s the uncomfortable truth: DIY landlords often cost themselves—and the market—more than they save. Poor screening, sloppy paperwork, and long vacancies don’t just hurt one property—they ripple out into the neighborhood and the wider rental market. Step 1: Pricing Mistakes That Hurt Everyone When landlords set rent based on guesswork instead of market data, they either: • Overprice the property → leaving it vacant for months, dragging down occupancy rates • Underprice the property → attracting low-quality applicants and undervaluing surrounding homes Professional property managers rely on current market comps, rental trend reports, and local demand analysis. DIY landlords often rely on Zillow guesses. The difference? Thousands of dollars lost and skewed rent expectations in the community. Step 2: Legal Risks That Spread Trouble Florida’s landlord-tenant laws are strict. Mishandling security deposits, skipping notice requirements, or filing sloppy evictions doesn’t just hurt the owner—it clogs the courts and creates bad tenant experiences that echo through the market. Common DIY mistakes: • Withholding deposits illegally • Delivering invalid 3-Day Notices • “Handshake agreements” with no enforceable lease Every time this happens, the reputation of local landlords suffers. Step 3: Screening Shortcuts That Backfire Tenant screening isn’t just pulling a credit report. It’s verifying rental history, checking for evictions, confirming employment, and reviewing background checks. DIY landlords who skip steps often end up renting to tenants who: • Pay late or not at all • Cause property damage • Disrupt neighbors and communities The result? More evictions, higher turnover, and properties that sit empty longer—hurting property values for everyone nearby. Step 4: Vacancy That Drains the Market A vacant property isn’t neutral—it’s a drag on the neighborhood. Overgrown lawns, empty driveways, and signs of neglect make an area less appealing. Professional managers move fast to re-rent properties. DIY landlords often underestimate how costly every extra week of vacancy really is. How Clover Property Management Protects the Market We don’t just protect individual owners—we help keep the Northwest Florida rental market stable, professional, and profitable. 🍀 Accurate pricing backed by market data 🍀 Full legal compliance with Florida landlord-tenant law 🍀 Rigorous tenant screening to protect neighborhoods 🍀 Fast turnover and professional marketing to reduce vacancy 🍀 Consistent property standards that preserve long-term value When landlords succeed the right way, everyone wins—homeowners, tenants, and the community. Ready to Stop Risking Your Investment? DIY management might look cheaper, but it usually costs more—in money, time, and stress. Don’t let guesswork damage your rental property or the market around it. 📲 Visit www.CloverPM.com or call 850-994-1542 for a free consultation with Clover Property Management. We raise the standard of property management in Pensacola—so your rental property performs like it should.